NJBallot — New Jersey News, Community by Community NJBallot

Newark Housing Authority board removed as HUD assumes control

Newark Housing Authority board removed as HUD assumes control

Two federal housing officials now hold the board's powers, and the authority says services for residents and voucher holders continue as usual. HUD's letter says the authority fell short of benchmarks in the 2024 recovery agreement it signed with the department.

Families in Newark's public housing or renting with Section 8 vouchers now have federal officials running the agency that serves them, after the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development removed the Newark Housing Authority's (NHA) board on Thursday.

HUD acted in a letter dated Thursday that says the city's housing authority missed targets it had agreed to meet under a 2024 recovery agreement with the federal agency. The letter removed the authority's board and relieved its members "of their duties as commissioners, effective immediately."

"NHA's day-to-day operations and resident services will continue as usual under HUD oversight," the authority said in a notice posted on its website the same day.

When HUD steps in at a housing agency, services to residents "will continue uninterrupted," federal rules say, "to the extent feasible."

A separate HUD order, also dated Thursday, says Newark's rent control, housing code and zoning laws no longer apply to the authority's properties.

Benjamin Hobbs, assistant secretary for HUD's Office of Public and Indian Housing, signed the letter. In a memo the same day, he handed the board's duties to two officials in his office: Shylon Ferry, deputy assistant secretary for its Assessment and Recovery Center, and Daniel Sherrod, associate deputy assistant secretary.

Either official can act alone, and together they now hold all of the board's duties and authority, the memo says. That includes decisions like the yearly and five-year plans the board had been set to take up on Nov. 20.

HUD's letter removes only the board. It does not remove the authority's executive director or its staff.

None of HUD's documents sets an end date for its control of the authority or for the order on city laws. Hobbs's memo gives Ferry and Sherrod the board's powers "until rescinded."

The authority runs the city's public housing and its voucher program

The Newark Housing Authority runs the city's public housing and the Housing Choice Voucher Program, the rent help better known as Section 8. More than 10,000 families get help through its programs, according to its website.

HUD pays for the voucher program, and the authority runs it in Newark. A voucher covers part of the monthly rent on an apartment for a household with a low or moderate income that rents from a private landlord, the authority's program page says.

The authority decides who qualifies, sends the program's share to the landlord on time and inspects apartments against federal health and safety standards.

HUD says the authority missed targets it agreed to in 2024

HUD scores each public housing agency under federal rules that give the most weight, 40 points, to the physical condition of its buildings. An agency's finances and its management count for 25 points each, and how promptly it puts its federal capital grants to work counts for 10. An agency that scores under 60 percent overall is rated a "troubled performer."

Federal rules require any agency rated troubled to sign a binding recovery agreement with HUD. The agreement sets performance targets, spells out the help HUD will give and states what happens if the agency falls short.

Patch reported in November 2023, citing TAPinto Newark, that the Newark authority had scored 39 percent on HUD's scorecard. HUD had rated the Newark authority a troubled performer, and the authority signed its recovery agreement with the department on Sept. 20, 2024, according to HUD's letter.

The rules give an agency rated troubled two years to make what HUD calls "substantial improvement," with a score target for each year. By the first, its score must close at least half the gap between its starting score and a passing one. By the second, it must pass.

In an example written into the rules, an agency starts at 50 points and needs 60 to pass. It must reach 55 points after the first year and 60 after the second.

If an agency is still rated troubled when the two years run out, the rules send its case to the HUD assistant secretary in charge of public housing, the post Hobbs holds.

HUD's letter says the authority missed both yearly score targets, overall and on the separate parts of the score. It would have missed them "even if HUD credited NHA additional points for its late FY 2024 financial filings," the letter adds. HUD's letter does not state the agreement's targets or the authority's scores.

"HUD regulations define 'substantial improvement' in quantitative, not qualitative, terms," the letter says.

HUD's default finding rested on three problems. On Sept. 22, HUD declared the authority in "substantial default" of its recovery agreement, saying it had missed targets for how many of its apartments were occupied. A second HUD letter, on Nov. 5, added two more: the authority's finances had not improved, and it had not filed financial reports as required.

HUD gave the authority 10 days after each letter to show in writing that the finding was wrong. The authority answered on Oct. 2 and Nov. 13.

HUD's letter describes the authority's two written replies. According to HUD, the replies acknowledged that the authority had missed the agreement's goals for occupancy and finances. They also argued that "the metrics improved given the circumstances" and that HUD had made its finding too soon.

The department found no basis to reverse its earlier findings. "HUD considered NHA's reported progress and claimed corrective efforts before determining whether further action is warranted. Those efforts do not outweigh the continued failure to meet benchmarks that NHA itself agreed to over two years ago," wrote Hobbs.

The letter rests on the U.S. Housing Act of 1937, a federal law. Once it declares a substantial default, HUD says in the letter, the department has "broad discretion" under that law, including the power to take "possession of all or part of" a housing agency.

Newark Mayor Ras Baraka said in a statement Friday that the city "does not run or manage" the authority. He said that before the takeover, the authority "was only about five points away from getting out of troubled status," and that the city wants assurance "that no tenants will be displaced," Patch reported.

A canceled board meeting was set to take up the authority's 2027 plans

NHA's board had been set to meet Friday afternoon to consider the authority's 2027 annual plan and five-year plan, according to a notice the authority posted Nov. 4. Proposed changes to the policies for its public housing and voucher programs were also on the agenda.

The annual plan lays out what the authority intends to do in the coming budget year, and the five-year plan sets longer-term goals. The proposed policy changes deal with who may move into public housing and stay there, and with how the voucher program runs.

Drafts had been open for public review since Sept. 21, and the authority held hearings on them Nov. 10. The authority was to review the comments from those hearings before the board acted.

The authority called off Friday's meeting in its Thursday notice and said word of future meetings will appear on its website. HUD and the authority have not said when the plans will next come up.

HUD says Newark's housing laws no longer apply to the authority

Sherrod, one of the two HUD officials now running the authority, declared in a letter to Baraka and in a separate memo, both dated Thursday, that Newark's rent control, housing code and zoning laws no longer apply to the authority's properties. The authority later posted both on its website. In his new role, he wrote, he can use powers that federal law gives the HUD secretary.

Federal housing law says that while HUD holds a housing agency, it "shall not be required to comply with" state and local laws in four areas if it finds in writing that they stand in the way of fixing a default. The areas are civil service, employee rights other than civil rights, purchasing, and "financial or administrative controls."

Sherrod wrote that the Newark code chapters are "local laws relating to financial or administrative controls" and that he is using that power "to abrogate" them, canceling them for the authority.

The chapters he names also cover construction code enforcement, trash, noise, streets and sidewalks, sewers and water, along with the housing code's armed security guard requirement.

The order also reaches any city rule that would let Newark inspect the authority's properties, fine the authority or charge it for city services it did not ask for. It covers only the authority's properties.

He also wrote that because HUD now holds the authority, its properties count as federally owned and do not have to follow building codes or zoning laws.

Federal inspection standards already cover the authority's buildings, and federal rules govern how its properties are used and redeveloped, Sherrod wrote. He added that fighting city inspections in municipal court would drain money the authority needs.

Sherrod wrote that the city laws stand in the way of his "ability to make the operational decisions necessary to recover the Housing Authority on behalf of the Federal government." Under his order, those decisions rest with HUD.

Related Articles

State board clears $77.44M for 274 income-restricted homes at Newark's old brewery and West Kinney

Sources

Code of Federal Regulations, Title 24, Part 902, "Public Housing Assessment System," sections 902.3, "Definitions," 902.9, "PHAS scoring," 902.11, "PHAS performance designation," 902.43, "Management operations performance standards," 902.50, "Capital Fund program assessment," and 902.75, "Troubled performers" (accessed Nov. 18, 2026)

Code of Federal Regulations, Title 24, Part 907, "Substantial Default by a Public Housing Agency," section 907.7, "Remedies for substantial default" (accessed Nov. 18, 2026)

Kiefer, Eric, Patch, "Feds Seize Control Of Large Public Housing Agency In North Jersey" (Nov. 20, 2026)

Newark Housing Authority, "Cancellation of Board of Commissioners Meeting," public notice (Nov. 19, 2026)

Newark Housing Authority, homepage, programs and services overview (accessed Nov. 20, 2026)

Newark Housing Authority, "Housing Choice Voucher Program (Section 8)" (accessed Nov. 20, 2026)

Newark Housing Authority, "Public Hearing & Opportunity for Public Comment: FY 2027 PHA Annual Plan, Five-Year Plan, ACOP, HCV Administrative Plan," public notice (Nov. 4, 2026)

Patch, Newark, "Newark Housing Authority Rates Low On Federal Scorecard: Report" (Nov. 22, 2023)

U.S. Code, Title 42, Section 1437d(j)(3)(D), U.S. Housing Act of 1937, Section 6(j)(3)(D) (2024 edition)

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Daniel Sherrod, Administrative Receiver, letter to Newark Mayor Ras J. Baraka, "Newark Housing Authority, Abrogation of Local Laws - Municipal Control, Oversight, Inspections, and Fees for Services" (Nov. 19, 2026)

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Daniel Sherrod, Administrative Receiver, memorandum, "Abrogation of Local Laws - Municipal Control, Oversight, Inspections, Fines, and Fees" (Nov. 19, 2026)

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Public and Indian Housing, Benjamin Hobbs, Assistant Secretary, letter to the Newark Housing Authority, "Final Determination of Substantial Default and Election of Remedies" (Nov. 19, 2026)

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Public and Indian Housing, Benjamin Hobbs, Assistant Secretary, memorandum, "NJ002 Newark Housing Authority Board of Commissioners, Redelegation of Authority" (Nov. 19, 2026)

Photo: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development