Republicans demand documents on the Motor Vehicle Commission's registration of roughly 6,600 ineligible people; the state calls the subpoena "political theater" with the Nov. 3 election days away.
House Republicans subpoenaed New Jersey's acting secretary of state, Shirley Emehelu, on Oct. 21, three days before in-person early voting begins. They demanded documents on the Motor Vehicle Commission's erroneous registration of roughly 6,600 people who indicated they were not U.S. citizens when registered. The subpoena seeks records on the error's discovery, the removal of ineligible registrants and the state's disclosures. The committees set a Nov. 16 production deadline, 13 days after the Nov. 3 election.
On July 21, the governor's office said customers answered "no" on a citizenship question at keypad stations, but "through no fault of their own, the system registered them anyway." The same statement said "fewer than 400 individuals who were newly registered for the first time because of the error voted." An Aug. 19 update broke the group into two categories: approximately 340 people registered through the error cast ballots, and another 220 affected individuals also voted but carried older registrations or separate attestations of eligibility, meaning their registrations may have been valid. The 340 figure is the number the state has stood by.
Representative Jeff Van Drew (R, NJ-02) opened the paper trail July 23 with a 12-question letter co-signed by 17 other House Republicans, with a response due Aug. 21. Four chairs demanded documents Aug. 3 with an Aug. 17 deadline: Judiciary's Jim Jordan (R-OH), Administration's Bryan Steil (R-WI), Elections Subcommittee's Laurel Lee (R-FL) and Oversight's Van Drew. On Aug. 17, committee staff and state counsel agreed to prioritize two categories: how the error was identified and the removal of ineligible registrants.
Four documents arrived Aug. 28; five more Sept. 11, including a one-paragraph Aug. 4 memo from the governor to then-Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell, and three IDEMIA emails. No state official testified at the Judiciary subcommittee's Sept. 15 hearing, "Restoring Election Integrity: Oversight of Voter Fraud in New Jersey." The subpoena release counts "only 12 total documents" produced in the "seventy-nine days" since the Aug. 3 demand.
The Motor Vehicle Commission's posted Q&A says individuals "indicated they were not United States citizens, and they did not attest to being eligible to vote during this transaction. But the software erroneously transmitted these individuals for voter registration processing regardless." The Q&A places the window between June 2023 and June 2024. Governor Mikie Sherrill has attributed the cause to a "serious software error."
IDEMIA, the identity-technology contractor that built the commission's registration system, disputes the state's account Company spokeswoman Lisa Shoemaker told USA Today that the state requested the June 2024 change as a routine system request with "no letter or formal notice" of an error.
IDEMIA says it has worked with New Jersey for more than 40 years, and GovTech reports it has received $61.1 million across three contracts. The administration was already rebidding the contract when the error surfaced, and IDEMIA lost to a lower bid by Thales in a competitive process, Shoemaker said. MVC Acting Chair and Chief Administrator Rosalie Johnson has said she expects to launch with the new vendor next year.
The governor's office puts the registrant population at roughly 6,600. The state moved 5,100 registrants to deleted status, determining they were registered only because of the error. The state rejected approximately 1,450 registrations, pending county review of their eligibility. Within the population, approximately 340 newly registered voters cast ballots, and about 220 affected people voted with older registrations or other records indicating possible eligibility. The rejected and prior-record cases went to county election officials.
The two sides agree on the count and nothing else
The Sherrill administration widened its review of commission registration processes on Oct. 7. It surfaced approximately 750 additional records tied to "no" answers on an age-eligibility question; dates of birth confirm those customers were old enough to vote and no underage person cast a ballot. CBS reported the mismatches appear to come from users pressing the wrong button on a PIN pad. The remaining approximately 340 records are linked to commission "re-entry events," registration transactions for people leaving prison, some of whom attested eligibility while incarcerated for indictable offenses. Neither category, the state says, involved noncitizens. New safeguards followed: re-entry eligibility signage, a PIN-pad confirmation of non-incarceration for indictable offenses and a daily automated audit before transmission.
"I'm focused on governing effectively. Republicans in Congress clearly aren't," Governor Sherrill said Oct. 21, calling the subpoena "political theater." A July 28 statement pledged the state would protect eligible voters from disenfranchisement while it corrected the rolls.
The state commissioned Chiesa Shahinian & Giantomasi PC, known as CSG Law, to investigate how the failure occurred, who knew and why registrations went unreviewed after the 2024 fix. The Globe describes it as a bipartisan firm led by Jeffrey Chiesa, a former U.S. senator and state attorney general under a Republican governor. Attorney General Jennifer Davenport's Oct. 20 safeguards announcement named no federal action.
"Hundreds actually voted," Van Drew said Oct. 21. "The state knew about this failure in 2024, and somehow these registrations remained on the rolls for nearly two years." Van Drew also said, "We did not blame Governor Sherrill for a failure that began under the Murphy administration, but she is responsible for providing answers now." The SAVE America Act, S. 1383, passed the House Feb. 11, 218-213; the Senate rejected it June 4, 48-50, and the House later attached it to the defense authorization bill, which the Senate has not passed.
A dismissed voter-data lawsuit and a records demand run beside the committees' inquiry
The Justice Department filed United States v. Caldwell, No. 3:26-cv-02025 (D.N.J.), on Feb. 26; a federal judge dismissed it with prejudice July 29, ruling that Title III does not reach the computerized voter list New Jersey maintains. The Justice Department appealed to the Third Circuit on Aug. 17.
Intervenors include the NAACP and a spring coalition of voting-rights groups, the League of Women Voters of New Jersey, the Latino Action Network and Make the Road New Jersey, plus an individual voter. The Justice Department separately demanded the 6,600 individuals' records on July 21, and Sherrill refused on July 28.
The New York Times has reported that some noncitizens registered through motor-vehicle transactions face denials of citizenship and removal proceedings. Sherrill said the state will not prosecute someone merely for having been registered improperly, the Globe reported, while the paper reports the Trump administration could still pursue noncitizens who voted in New Jersey, a possibility the governor has acknowledged.
Van Drew's July 23 letter pointed to two tied races, a general election for borough council in Oakland (Bergen) and a Democratic council primary in Roselle (Union), asking whether affected rolls could have changed outcomes. Beth Thompson, administrator of the Hunterdon County Board of Elections and president of the New Jersey Association of Election Officials, has raised disenfranchisement concerns.
State Sen. Anthony Bucco (R, 25th District), the Senate Republican leader, says Ocean County removed more than 100 affected registrants, 12 of whom voted, some on paper forms bypassing the keypad. Bucco and state Sen. Kristin Corrado sponsor a bill creating a seven-member Senate committee to investigate the glitches, end automatic commission registration, require documentary proof of citizenship to register and mandate bi-annual audits.
The acting secretary of state's production deadline is Nov. 16. Van Drew has warned the investigation could fade if Democrats win back the House. Early voting begins Oct. 24.
Related Articles
NJ early voting starts Saturday: What to know for the Nov. 3 election
Davenport Sues Trump as NJ Primary Opens — Federal Hearing Set for Election Day
Governor Sherrill Signs Early Voting Expansion Amid Federal Election Policy Changes
Sources
CBS News New York, "report on the Oct. 7 MVC disclosure," (Oct. 7, 2026)
Democracy Docket, "New Jersey Voter Roll Records Challenge II case page," (Sept. 22, 2026)
Democracy Docket, "New Jersey DOJ Voter Data Access Challenge case page," (Aug. 17, 2026)
Fox News, "RNC sues New Jersey election officials over alleged withheld voter roll records," (Sept. 22, 2026)
GovTech, "N.J. Moves to Replace Software Blamed for Voting Glitch," (July 28, 2026)
House Committee on the Judiciary, "House Republicans Subpoena New Jersey Secretary of State for Information on the State Registering Over 6,000 Noncitizens to Vote," (Oct. 21, 2026)
House Committee on the Judiciary, "Aug. 3 records demand letter," (Aug. 3, 2026)
House Committee on the Judiciary, "subpoena cover letter and release," (Oct. 21, 2026)
Legis1, "coverage of the Sept. 15 hearing and SAVE Act legislation," (Sept. 2026)
Madeleine Ngo, Nick Corasaniti and Hamed Aleaziz, The New York Times, "Homeland Security Intensifies Pursuit of Noncitizens on Voter Rolls," (Aug. 10, 2026)
NJBIZ, "Sherrill: MVC error registered 6,600 noncitizens," (July 22, 2026)
New Jersey Division of Elections, "Guide to MVC Voter Registration Error," (Aug. 19, 2026)
New Jersey Globe, "coverage of the Van Drew letter and county responses," (July 21, 2026)
New Jersey Globe, "coverage of the Van Drew letter," (July 23, 2026)
New Jersey Globe, "coverage of county responses," (Aug. 7, 2026)
New Jersey Globe, "Sherrill's response to House Republicans," (Aug. 21, 2026)
New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission, "MVC System Error portal and Q&A," (Oct. 22, 2026)
New Jersey Office of the Attorney General, "release on 2026 election safeguards," (Oct. 20, 2026)
Office of the Governor, "statement on the MVC error," (July 21, 2026)
Office of the Governor, "statement on voter-roll remediation," (July 28, 2026)
Office of the Governor, "update on the MVC issue," (Aug. 19, 2026)
Office of the Governor, "statement on additional MVC records," (Oct. 7, 2026)
Office of the Governor, "statement on the House subpoena," (Oct. 21, 2026)
The Philadelphia Inquirer, "More than 2000 of N.J.'s 'noncitizen voters' could actually…," (July 28, 2026)
Politico, "report on the House subpoena," (Oct. 21, 2026)
J. Justin Riemer, The House Judiciary Committee, "written statement, Restoring Election Integrity hearing record," (Sept. 15, 2026)
Rep. Jeff Van Drew, "letter to New Jersey officials," (July 23, 2026)
Rep. Jeff Van Drew, "statement on the subpoena," (Oct. 21, 2026)
U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey, "memorandum opinion, United States v. Caldwell," (July 29, 2026)
U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on the Judiciary, "Restoring Election Integrity: Oversight of Voter Fraud in New Jersey hearing record," (Sept. 15, 2026)
USA Today, "Registering noncitizens to vote in NJ not our error, contractor says," (July 26, 2026)
WHYY, "Reforms to New Jersey voter registration at MVC announced," (Oct. 8, 2026)
Photo: Tomwsulcer / Wikimedia Commons (CC0 1.0)